Fiance Cheater

Summary: I want to tell my friend that his fiance cheated on him but my girlfriend won't let me.
Stakes: To tell or not to tell

— "Stakes" are what the loser of the case owes the winner (e.g. "Dinner and a movie," "two kicks to the groin," etc.).

Plaintiff
Files
Case
Defendant
Appears
In Court
Plaintiff
Enters
Opening
Arguments
Defendant
Enters
Opening
Arguments
Plaintiff
Enters
Closing
Arguments
Defendant
Enters
Closing
Arguments
The Jury
Votes
The Verdict
Is Delivered
Username: Sir Grapefellow
Age: 30
City: Phoenix
Sex: male
Status: Citizen
an Instant Jury virgin
Username: MandM
Age: 31
City: phoenix
Sex: female
Status: Citizen
an Instant Jury virgin
Voting Results:
Sir Grapefellow (0%)
MandM (100%)

Tell Your Friends About this Case!

Plaintiff Arguments [Feb 3, 2009]

Wow...this one is TOUGH. We really need some help here.


My best friend is engaged to my fiance's best friend. We always hang out together so the four of us have become very close.

 

We went to a  Super Bowl party with a large number of people because we are naturally Cards fans. My friend went to the game in Tampa so his fiance came with us.


The party started early so we got really, really, really drunk. We were having a blast (besides the outcome of the game of course) so the night continued pretty late. There as a handful of people still partying but most had cleared out.

I had to work the next day so I had to wrap things up. I went to look for my gal who I thought was outside having a smoke. When I opened the door, I see my boys fiance locking lips with another dude. They didnt even see me. I ducked back in and thankfully found my gal standing right behind me. I sent her out to break it up.

 

We grabbed a cab home with drunken friends fiance who was extremely wasted. She had no idea what she had just done. I decided to play dumb until I could sort it out with my woman.

 

This is a damned if you do damned if you dont situation. I feel that being drunk is not really an excuse. Then again, I really don't want to expose this if it was a mistake. They are very happy together and I love both of them. But, i feel that keeping this from my friend would be betraying him but by telling him, my fiance may be betraying her best friend.

 

HELP!

Defendant Arguments [Feb 3, 2009]

So now you know the situation, here is my side of the story.

 

My friend knows I saw her but does not think anyone else did. She does not remember it all. She didnt even believe me when I told her. She as CRUSHED and has been crying for 3 days. She made me promise that I would not tell my man but little does she know, he saw it firsthand.

 

I did not recognize the guy so I feel as if it would not get out through any other source. However, I feel that she truly made a mistake and we should leave it at that. She was totally not herself this day. The excitement in this city was higher than it has ever been so I think we all just got a little carried away.

 

I think we should let the two of them sort it out and pretend we know nothing.

Plaintiff Closing Arguments [Feb 4, 2009]

I'm pretty sure that we are not the only ones that know about this. The guy she hooked up with had to know someone at that party and may have said something. I would rather him hear it from her than us but the worst would be if he heard it from someone else. If he did, we would all look like we were betraying him.

 

I have been friends with this guy since the day we were born. He would expect me to say something. If it breaks them up, maybe it was all for the better.

Defendant Closing Arguments [Feb 4, 2009]

This WILL not get out. I do not want to even think of what it would be like to ruin their relationship and never see either of them again.

This was a stupid mistake that was made on a very drunken night. The remorse is there, the heartache is there, we do not need to do anything else.

 

The lesson has been learned. Lets leave it at that for all of our sakes. Some things are better left unsaid. End of story.

Jurors:

Flash

Notre...

The...

Lady

summe...

Wakebrdr

hilt

rockr...

Cass

summe...

NJ...

Message Board

Flash wrote:[Feb 3, 2009]
Tough
This is a tough one. I think I need to hear more. Sounds like either way, someone will get hurt.
Anonymous wrote:[Feb 3, 2009]
Slut
If she did it once she'll do it again. Her slut mentality was just buried in the back of her brain. A few drinks just allowed it to come out. What would happen if she went further with the guy and got pregnant? And then didnt remember it? Would she pawn of the child as her husbands? Rat that broad out.
Wakebrdr wrote:[Feb 3, 2009]
Let it go
Why not just pretend you were drunk and you didnt see it? I'd mind my own. If you say something, he may stay with her anyway and it could hurt your relationship.
hilt wrote:[Feb 4, 2009]
Mind Your Own Backyard
Enough said
Anonymous wrote:[Feb 4, 2009]
tell
you have to tell. be a man.
Anonymous wrote:[Feb 5, 2009]
hmmmmmm
I'm sensing a little too much sympathy from the plaintiff's fiance. Are we sure she hasn't acted the same way at some parties where the plaintiff wasn't present? Or maybe the plaintiff's fiance cheated on him with the plaintiff's best friend, which is why she doesn't want to bring the subject of cheating up.
NJ Bullet wrote:[Feb 5, 2009]
no way
...it's just not your place. What if your friend becomes irrational and get pissed at you. I've seen friendships end over less than this. Think about it - you and your friend don't stand to gain anything from this.
Anonymous wrote:[Feb 15, 2009]
Kill the messenger....
Don't be the messenger!! If they are truly in love, they will stay together anyway - despite this bump in the road. Then you will be the friend that 'tried to break them up.' Never insert yourself in a friend's relationship. I know you've known him since birth, but if he loves her, he will side with her and you will be 'the dead messenger.'
Anonymous wrote:[Feb 27, 2009]
i
agree with slut. She is just going to cheat on him, catch alot of STD's, give it to him and then look at the mess she caused. Do her once more, than bag her azz

You can leave your message:
Message Title:
*Message:
*Verification Code:
Summary: G let the kids watch a scary movie now they are in...
Stakes: 5 mins of a massage for every...
 VS. 
Boozer GBlev...
Age:  42 41
City:  Newport... Newport...
Sex:  female male
Plaintiff is Now Entering Arguments
Time Remaining:
15:46:08
Summary: Heiny is that guy at the movies who comments at will...
Stakes: Zip it and a Triple Treat Combo...
 VS. 
Hooks HeinY
Age:  25 32
City:  Portland Portland
Sex:  male male
The Jury is Deliberating
Time Remaining:
33:47:55
Summary: My brother likes Asian women but my mother will only...
Stakes: Do what YOU want to do and I...
 VS. 
Might... Prince
Age:  24 29
City:  New York New York
Sex:  male male
The Jury is Deliberating
Time Remaining:
11:53:08