Is this party for me?

Summary: My girlfriend through me a party...with all of her friends as guest.
Stakes: Dinner.Alone.

— "Stakes" are what the loser of the case owes the winner (e.g. "Dinner and a movie," "two kicks to the groin," etc.).

Plaintiff
Files
Case
Defendant
Appears
In Court
Plaintiff
Enters
Arguments
Defendant
Enters
Arguments
The Jury
Votes
The Verdict
Is Delivered
Username: Casper
Age: 31
City: Chicago
Sex: male
Status: Citizen
an Instant Jury virgin
Username: hotchick
Age: 28
City: Chicago
Sex: female
Status: Citizen
an Instant Jury virgin
Voting Results:
Casper (77.3%)
hotchick (22.7%)

Tell Your Friends About this Case!

Plaintiff Arguments [Aug 4, 2009]

My girlfriend through me a huge 30th birthday party last weekend. Now, before I get this off on the wrong foot and sound like a complainer, the party was fun and I told her that I appreciated the effort.

So why are we here today? Well, the party of 25 people consisted solely of her friends except for my cousin and his girlfriend. I didnt even know 5 of the girls there. I basically sat at the end of the bar while my honey and her bees played catch up.

 

I think it was a nice effort but cmon...the party wasnt for me.

Defendant Arguments [Aug 5, 2009]

You buy the man a pot of gold, he tell's you its not shiny enough.

 

You forgot to mention that your closest friend lives 3 hrs away. I didnt want to put it on anyone to have to fly in. Sorry you didnt have fun. Was just trying to make you feel as good as you could on your big day.

Jurors:

You...

goose

thebaz

Shiny...

kamel

tanya...

russian

ChuckC

billd...

DUKE

Bammer

askme

pande...

Hexzi...

Newma...

e.abby

katwhat

D-Rex

mhulsey

bmorekt

ladylove

Makeu...

Orbit

makay...

Andy

syph90

hazel...

hollyS24

Mark1982

jb87

Pete

clarebcw

shiBbs

emilooo

alexi...

Leide...

JoFuS

runne...

missy724

steph...

Xoeleeox

raelee

dance286

Ashmanda

Agiam...

sever...

huske...

Straw...

Agent...

xoxje...

harle...

vogue

adiab...

sxxyg...

ksamm...

mrsrp...

CatieM

wolfs...

You'v...

Aeva

Kryst...

Weishar

movie...

prncs...

greg#7

anmar...

casey...

music...

TheFi...

TheTi...

loved...

xojam...

Coldw...

Allis...

M1lks...

AnnaK...

Lee-S...

auron...

LESC20

redve...

steak...

Swish...

wwetn...

artju...

Dafrp...

Boots

nickt...

skiba...

bambam

ruthi...

Scrins

Valer...

Crazy...

Eden-...

steph...

jaybles

hillarys

caitl...

Sharlet1

scata...

ecast...

lyssa7

mmeleka

MissB...

ike45x95

404XEEN

dillo...

Danjor

tayta...

Alexa...

conner11

BriBir

raguirre

mags1387

TheRe...

jenna212

lmorg...

TubaP...

Cody

Linds...

VikVa...

penpento

EPICx...

Swatty

JReece22

cartw...

kickl...

Sara

McNasty

thatw...

emmab...

jo060

julie...

Dance...

Emmal...

brean...

briat...

laure...

gcbilly2

shann...

imagi...

DuhAs...

knigh...

lawfull

SG51090

EvilP...

rrh0t...

TheWi...

Trees

foxgi...

crist...

xoxkr...

LalaBoo

Cassa13

fresh...

mandy...

Pietr...

ilmbgft

silve...

missh...

WTFF

mrodz

noell...

D3rty...

Tiger...

phill...

jayja...

queen...

jessi...

LaMancha

ohmyj...

sierraxx

Natal...

camar...

Lcper...

Tacom...

gabri...

emagg...

Rusty

jassyj08

ap2663

Murde...

kara_...

tomfe...

FOR-N...

livyb...

freedom

phant...

nycraigx

RichC...

mmmmgie

rseba...

nutme...

Buey

anwozny

thene...

erika...

lisal...

oxBec...

divin...

Message Board

huskers23 wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
3 hours isn't that far away...i've driven it before to see a friend....did you even invite his closest friends?
Weishar wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
Thats a pretty pathetic excuse. You say his friend had to fly? I have friends who arent even my best friends that live 3 hours away and I still go see them pretty regularly. In a car. not a plane. Id definitely go 3 hours for my friends birthday. And that was just your excuse for his closest friend. what about the rest of his friends? You act like he only has one friend. Pretty insulting. Im sure he has plenty of friends who would have been there if you would have made the effort. Just admit you used his birthday as a selfish excuse to have get all your friends over. He should never feel awkward for his birthday. You say you get him a pot of gold and its not shiny enough? where are the examples of these pots of gold? you dont have any
You've Been Served wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
What?!?
So what your saying is your to lazy to call any of his friends and invite them? So I'll just call mine and that'll do. IF your throwing a party for someone ELSE then you have to invite THEIR friends, Not yours.
M1lkshak3 wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
I understand where the defendant stands trying to make it special but if you were put in the same situation you would be furious... The best thing would have been to spend his birthday with just you and him if his friends could not make it.
Boots wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
At least invite the friends. If they were invited and couldn't make it then it isn't your fault, but you didn't even give them the chance. I would have driven three hours for my best friends birthday party.
Anonymous wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
The Party
It seems like it was really nice for throwing you a Birthday party. However, to not invite any of his friends for his own Birthday party seems a bit strange. It doesn't matter how far away his friends are, an invite is an invite. I've been invited to some of my friend's bday parties who lived 1200 miles away. The question to ask his girlfriend, if he was to throw you a Birthday party, and you show up, and it's just his friends - How would that make you feel? Use this as a learning experience and let it go. I'm sure it took alot of effort to put it all together, and it seems he is thankful for that.
Alexadenise wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
The party
The guy's gonna win. You have a pathetic excuse. its bullshit. Hun, its HIS birthday party.. NOT YOURS. It is NOT all about you. HORRIBLE effort. You could have invited his friends. If they're REALLY his CLOSE friends, they would've done the 3 hour drive. 3 hour drive, they wouldn't fly! Are you kidding? Not fooling anyone.
VikVaughn wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
hmm.
Why didn't you just give him crazy sex? who wants a party at thirty with your friends? Sorry lady you're greedy. and Dude, you need to make some friends.
cartwrite wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
Okay. once and for all
Dude, Really?! U are a d-bag. It's not a "surprise" party is it? She "through"(lol on ur spelling)THREW u a party. So she shoulda got some decorations and some food/drinks/snacks/e­tc and maybe a DJ. But if none of "your" friends were there then either u dont have any friends or ur a lame-o who didnt tell them. Why wouldnt u invite ur friends/coworkers/wh­oever yourself? I mean, u only see or talk to them everyday. You sound sad. Your girl should give you a hug. And a word to the wise-stop watching so much lifetime TV. Its affecting your mood swings. =D
Anonymous wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
lets clarify this... is it a 3 hour drive- or a 3 hour flight?
jo060 wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
Happy late B-day man. Unless you have only 1 friend she should have invited more of your friends. And she could have at LEAST sat with you and talk with you instead of with her buddies. After all it was YOUR b-day. Girls get all 364 days of the year. +1 to you bro.
j.jordan8:) wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
i think she is right on this one!
j.jordan8:) wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
i think she is right on this one!
rrh0tm0ney wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
she coulda just had anothr party and invited then, or email or facebook or somethin
Trees wrote:[Aug 5, 2009]
The girl was right. Talk about ungrateful. :/ Dump him :0!
nutmeg757 wrote:[Aug 6, 2009]
Come ON!
I gotta vote with the chick for 2 major reasons: 1. If you are 30 and you can't properly distinguish between the use of the words "through" and "threw", then you lose all credibility with me. 2. If it is your 30th Bday and your friends are calling you up or throwing you a surprise party, your girl was only probably the only one you had that gave a crap. And thank goodness her friends took enough pity on you to show up!
Anonymous wrote:[Aug 6, 2009]
Terrible
nutmeg757 that is exactly what i thought about through and threw, seriously if he can't tell the difference then he doesn't get my vote.
Anonymous wrote:[Aug 6, 2009]
Terrible
nutmeg757 that is exactly what i thought about through and threw, seriously if he can't tell the difference then he doesn't get my vote.
lamb2k wrote:[Feb 6, 2010]
I agree with the plaintiff, were his friends even invited? your wife sounds wack my man...cmonson!

You can leave your message:
Message Title:
*Message:
*Verification Code:
Summary: G sold a man a printer on craigslist that he knew...
Stakes: If the man calls back, give him...
 VS. 
Gigi25 McG
Age:  23 24
City:  Bryn Mawr Bryn Mawr
Sex:  female male
The Jury is Deliberating
Time Remaining:
55:18:49
Summary: My boyfriend is going to a football game this...
Stakes: You go to the party if I win,...
 VS. 
peerless scroix
Age:  28 29
City:  Meridan New Yorik
Sex:  female male
The Jury is Deliberating
Time Remaining:
93:00:19
Summary: We call my friend 'the knife' because he constantly...
Stakes: Each interruption = a shot of...
 VS. 
The... smeltz
Age:  28 27
City:  Philade... Philade...
Sex:  male male
The Jury is Deliberating
Time Remaining:
29:16:00
Summary: My brother is staying at my place since he broke up...
Stakes: She is not allowed over anymore...
 VS. 
McCain wallace
Age:  34 29
City:  Phoenix Tempe
Sex:  male male
The Jury is Deliberating
Time Remaining:
68:49:03
www.screenpens.wordpress.com